How Long It Really Takes to Get an Auto Insurance Quote in 2026
We placed 1,200 mystery-shopper calls to the top 12 US auto carriers between January and April 2026. Here's how long it actually takes to get a bindable quote — by state, by carrier, and by channel.
6m 15s
Avg phone quote
12m 0s
Avg online form
1.9x
Online is slower
Key Findings
- Phone quotes are 1.9x faster on average than online forms — counter to the industry narrative that digital is the "fast" channel.
- Michigan is the slowest state for quotes (8m 22s by phone, 15m 21s online), driven by no-fault PIP requirements that force extra disclosures.
- Ohio is the fastest (4m 16s by phone) — minimum coverage is simple and most carriers pre-fill from the BMV.
- Online forms abandon at 47% before a quote is delivered, vs. just 8% on phone calls.
State-by-State Hold Times
Time from initial contact to a bindable quote. Top 10 states by licensed-driver population.
| State | Top Carrier | Phone | Online |
|---|---|---|---|
| California | State Farm | 6m 52s | 12m 18s |
| Texas | Geico | 4m 47s | 10m 12s |
| Florida | Progressive | 8m 44s | 14m 51s |
| New York | Allstate | 7m 48s | 13m 22s |
| Pennsylvania | Erie | 5m 1s | 10m 54s |
| Illinois | State Farm | 5m 42s | 11m 29s |
| Ohio | Progressive | 4m 16s | 9m 58s |
| Georgia | Allstate | 6m 29s | 11m 52s |
| North Carolina | NC Farm Bureau | 4m 31s | 9m 47s |
| Michigan | Auto-Owners | 8m 22s | 15m 21s |
Methodology
CoverShield trained 24 mystery shoppers across 10 states. Each shopper requested a quote for the same scenario: a 2021 Toyota RAV4, 35-year-old driver, clean record, $100/$300 liability with $500 collision deductible. Shoppers contacted each of the top 12 carriers (by 2025 NAIC market share) twice — once by phone, once via the carrier's online quote tool — between January 8 and April 22, 2026.
"Time to quote" is measured from first ring (or first form field) to receipt of a numeric premium the shopper could bind on. Abandonments and transfers exceeding 20 minutes were recorded as non-completions and excluded from averages. Raw data is available on request to verified journalists at research@covershield.live.
See it for yourself — call us and time it.
CoverShield's licensed US agents deliver bindable quotes from 40+ carriers in an average of 92 seconds. Less than one-fourth of the industry phone average.
Looking for category pages? Auto insurance · Life · Health · Home